Safest and Most Dangerous States for Drivers

Safest and Most Dangerous States for Drivers

By

Kaz Weida

Researcher & Writer

May 23, 2023Share Article

SafeWise is an independent review site. We may earn money when you click links on our site. Learn how we rank and review.

Do drivers in your state cross the line and go over the limit? SafeWise investigates.

Safest States for Drivers
Safest States for DriversFatality rate per 1,000 drivers1. Massachusetts.0482. Rhode Island.0493. New York.0524. New Jersey.0625. Washington.0646. Minnesota.0667. Hawaii.0668. Connecticut .0699. Vermont.07010. New Hampshire.071

Most Dangerous States for Drivers
Most Dangerous States for DriversFatality rate per 1,000 drivers1. Louisiana.15842. South Dakota.15843. South Carolina.16844. Alabama.16945. Oklahoma .17146. Wyoming.17847. Mississippi.18448. Montana .18649. New Mexico.20350. North Dakota.256

Your security on the road depends on many factors. Seat belts, road conditions, and, perhaps most alarmingly, other drivers. Unintentional injury is the leading cause of death for people under fifty in America, and over 37,000 people die yearly in motor vehicle incidents1. When it comes to driver safety, however, there may be another important factor to consider: where you live.
Because protecting your family doesn’t end at home, SafeWise is also committed to keeping you safe on the road. We researched driving trends across America, aggregating data on motor vehicle fatalities to determine the safest place to drive.
Our conclusion? The northeastern United States, where the old salts in New England manage to keep the rubber on the road, is your safest bet. Despite a reputation for aggressive driving (and some rather unsavory nicknames), Massachusetts’s drivers earn top marks, followed by their neighbors in Rhode Island.
Planning a road trip? Take caution on some of the northwestern cross-country routes that cover scenic areas in Wyoming, Montana, and North Dakota. These mostly rural regions hit road blocks as some of the most dangerous states for driving in America. 
Looking for more specifics on your state’s safety record? Let’s compare numbers to see a few other correlations in the data on driving trends across America.

Fast is fatal
Despite having longer average commute times,2 states with lower speed limits have fewer fatalities.3 The data shows that while you might spend more time on the road, chances are you’ll get there safely when traveling at slower speeds.

Fewest Speeding Fatalities
StateAverage Commute Time (minutes)Average Highway Speed Limit (mph)Speeding Fatalities Per 1,000 ResidentsNew Jersey30.4620.0111Massachusetts28650.0113Rhode Island23.6580.0114Virginia27.7680.0121Florida25.9690.0121
Most Speeding Fatalities
StateAverage Commute Time (minutes)Average Highway Speed Limit (mph)Speeding Fatalities Per 1,000 ResidentsWyoming18.3750.0819North Dakota16.9710.0661South Carolina23.5650.0623New Mexico21.6680.0619Montana18700.0503And while there’s plenty of controversy surrounding the argument that stricter blood alcohol thresholds mean less DUIs,5 there is evidence that higher blood alcohol content (BAC) levels in general mean more fatalities. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration indicated that in 70% of alcohol-impaired driving fatalities,6 at least one driver had a BAC of .15 or higher, nearly twice the legal limit in every state. Conversely, states with higher average speed limits see more fatalities. But it’s worth noting that many of the states listed as the most dangerous for speeding are also northern or southern states that have major cross-country interstate highways. What the fatality data may show instead is the result of higher speeds, more congestion, and heavier vehicles.
If you’re just passing through Wyoming or North Dakota, maybe don’t keep the pedal to the metal.

More lenient laws mean more DUIs. Except when they don’t.
Three of the states that see the most fatalities from drunk driving are also considered more lenient on DUIs, according to WalletHub.4 But that’s not the end of the story. Two states from the safest category also make the most lenient list, so we’ll have to refrain from speculation because the data here is a mixed bag.

Fewest Drunk Driving Fatalities
StateDUIs Per 1,000 ResidentsDrunk Driving Fatalities per 1,000 ResidentsRhode Island26.30.0180New York1.270.0191Utah2.300.0210Minnesota5.430.0220Vermont4.230.0224
Most Drunk Driving Fatalities
StateDUIs Per 1,000 ResidentsDrunk Driving Fatalities per 1,000 ResidentsWyoming12.210.0904North Dakota5.290.0872Montana4.100.0833Mississippi3.890.0692New Mexico4.670.0691At SafeWise, we wondered if Uber or Lyft helped cut down on drunk driving in states where ridesharing is more popular, but studies have indicated that’s not the case.

Age is only a number, but it’s also a factor in distracted driving.
Think keeping both hands on the wheel is your ticket to safety? It’s certainly important, but it doesn’t seem to be the defining factor in fatalities associated with careless driving. Only one of the safest states with the fewest distracted drivers bans handheld phone use.7

Fewest Distracted Driving Fatalities
StateDoes the state ban handheld cellphone use?Distracted Driving Fatalities per 1,000 ResidentsMinnesotaNo0.00364NebraskaNo0.00580IowaNo0.00736VermontYes0.00799MaineNo0.00827
Most Distracted Driving Fatalities
StateDoes the state ban handheld cellphone use?Distracted Driving Fatalities per 1,000 ResidentsNew Mexico(only bans in state vehicles)0.0379FloridaNo0.0359DelawareYes0.0296NevadaYes0.0270Louisiana(drivers with permit or intermediate license)0.0250What does appear to be a factor? A state’s median age. At least one of the most dangerous states for distracted driving is in the top ten lowest median ages in the US, and two of the states with less distracted drivers have the highest median age in the United States.8 It’s likely that younger, inexperienced drivers just can’t handle distractions of any sort.
There’s another interesting correlation between distracted driving and the age of your vehicle’s occupants. States considered the worst in America for distracted driving also have higher than average birthrates.8 As you might imagine, those with babies on board may be more concerned about what’s going on in the back seat than what’s happening on the road ahead.

Our Methodology
SafeWise’s methodology in this study on the Safest and Most Dangerous States for Driving is based on data from the Insurance Institution for Highway Safety Highway Loss Data Institute on driving fatalities in each state. The team then sorted by causation and supported correlations with additional resources where indicated.
Buckle up and share this map with the ones you love before taking the wheel in your state.  

Compare the top car safety products
ProductBest forPriceSpecsStand-out featureLearn moreRead reviewDroneMobile X-1Best car alarm$119.953,000 ft rangeRemote startDiesel engine safeView on AmazonRead reviewRexing V1PBest dash cam$139.284K Full HD170° front and rearTolerates -20°F to 176°FView on AmazonRead reviewVyncsBest vehicle tracker$89.99OBD port plug-inMaintenance remindersView on AmazonRead reviewTorin Big RedBest portable car jack$26.99Lifts up to 15 in. and 3,000 lbs.LightweightAffordableView on AmazonRead reviewGarmin DriveSmart 61Best navigation system$249.996.95 in. touchscreenVoice controlView on AmazonRead reviewThe Club 3000Steering wheel lock$49.64Hardened steel3 different sizesTamperproof lockView on AmazonRead review*Data as of post date. Offers and availability may vary by location and are subject to change. SafeWise uses paid Amazon links.

Related articles on SafeWise

The Safest and Most Dangerous Roads on New Year’s
The Best and Worst States for Driving in Bad Weather
Car Safety Guide
The Dangers and Costs of Distracted Driving in Your State
How Do I Talk to My Teen About Driver Responsibility and Safety?
5 Tips to Make You Safer on the Road

Sources
1. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, “National Statistics”2. United States Census Bureau, “Mean Travel Time to Work of Workers 16 Years and Over Who Did Not Work at Home (Minutes)3. Governors Highway Safety Association, “Speeding and Aggressive Driving”4. WalletHub, “Strictest and Most Lenient States On DUI”5. Daily Herald, “Small Percentage of DUI Arrests Made Under 0.08; Police Arrest on Impairment”6. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, “Traffic Safety Facts”7. Governors Highway Safety Association, “Distracted Driving”8. The Denver Post, “Chart: Compare the Average Age in Each US State, 2005–2014”9. Business Insider, “Here Are the States Where People Are Having the Most Babies”

Share Article

Written by

Kaz Weida

Kaz is a journalist who covers home security, parenting, and community and child safety. Her work and product testing in the security and safety field spans the past four years. You can find Kaz in HuffPost, SheKnows, Lifehack, and much more. Her degree in education and her background as a teacher and a parent make her uniquely suited to offer practical advice on creating safe environments for your family.

Read More

Recent Articles

By Katie McEntire

05/19/2023

Best Wireless Home Security Systems

Wireless home security systems are more popular than ever. They’re easy to install and hard…

By Rebecca Edwards

05/18/2023

10 Best Home Security Systems of 2023

After hundreds of hours of tests and research, plus a combined 50+ years of experience,…

By Cathy Habas

05/17/2023

Best Medical Alert Necklaces

If you find yourself in an emergency, a medical alert necklace can contact trained professionals…

By John Carlsen

05/17/2023

Best DIY Home Security Systems of 2023

SimpliSafe is the best DIY home security system because it’s cost-efficient, effective, and easy to…